The Illinois Commerce Commission approved a rate hike for Peoples Gas rate hike at their meeting Thursday, but only $40.3 million, a 72% cut from the utility's proposal.
Peoples Gas' was requesting a $144 million rate hike. Regulators agreed to the hike, but have not yet said whether they are approving the full $144 million amount or a lesser percentage of the request.
The ICC said in a news release that they struck $103.7 million from the rate request for natural gas delivery services, representing a rate hike approximately 72% lower than what the utility wanted. They also approved a 9.45% return on equity for both utilities, down from the requested 10.10%.
"Affordability and risk reduction are critical concerns in any ICC utility proceeding. The ICC's responsibility is to balance the interests of Illinois' utilities and their consumers, and the increase approved today reflects a fair and reasonable determination reached over the course of an 11-month legal proceeding," said ICC Chairman Doug Scott in a statement.
Jim Chilsen, director of communications for the Citizens Utility Board, a watchdog group that has staunchly opposed the rate hike, said the ICC's ruling is "a step in the right direction."
"That is progress, but it's still bitter news to a lot of Peoples Gas customers who are having a hard time affording their bills," he said.
Chilsen has been at the forefront of the fight to make living in Chicago more affordable. He's not alone
"The commission significantly cut the proposed increase, but it still is an increase," said Abe Scarr, director of the Illinois Public Interest Research Group, a nonprofit consumer advocacy group.
Alvaro Oberegon, associate state director for advocacy and outreach at AARP Illinois, said affordability is the top concern for seniors on fixed incomes, and higher utility bills could mean not being able to afford medication or groceries.
"These utility companies, they're like a runaway freight train, right? I mean, they come back year after year requesting these hikes that are really on the backs of consumers," he said.
If the rate hike had been approved in full, the average household would have seen a $7-$8 increase on their monthly gas bill starting in 2027. The exact cost of the approved increase for customers on their monthly bills was not yet known.
While it's unclear what the average customer's bill will look like after the rate hike, the extra charge should be less than earlier projections, and ultimately will depend on each customer's energy usage and service class.
Peoples Gas, which is the largest natural gas supplier in Northern Illinois and has nearly 900,000 customers in the city of Chicago alone, requested a $202 million rate increase in January before lowering the ask to the current $144 million figure later in the year.
In a statement, Peoples Gas said in part, "We understand the commission today approved our continued pipe retirement plans, however today's decision to cut $25 million in critical day-to-day safety work is surprising and extremely disappointing."
Peoples Gas spokesman David Schwartz said the spending was necessary to retire 1,000 miles of pipes as directed by the commission and characterized the advocates' demonstration as political.
But there has been pushback on the proposal from consumers and watchdog groups, and even in the ICC itself. In October, administrative law judges at the ICC submitted a proposed order that recommended lowering the rate hike to $66.2 million.
The ICC appears to be asking Peoples Gas to look for alternate ways to fix outdated pipes.
"Neither state nor federal directives dictate that pipe replacement is the only option the utility can use to meet such requirements," ICC Chairman Doug Scott said.
Consumer advocates like CUB, Illinois PIRG, and the AARP are calling for overhaul of Peoples Gas' embattled program to retire aging lead pipes in order to help its customers lower their bills.
At the end of October, consumer groups hand-delivered more than 10,000 petitions urging regulators to reject the rate hike.
A group of alderpersons and consumer advocates from CUB and the Illinois Public Interest Research Group say since 2011, Peoples Gas has raised rates by nearly $500 million.
CUB and PIRG have strongly opposed the rate hike proposals, saying they include hidden bonuses for corporate executives, inflated profit margins and wasteful spending on the Pipe Retirement Program.
The rate hikes could hit consumers' bills as soon as next month, and would be spaced out over the course of the next year.
Capitol News Illinois contributed to this report.